By Andrew Buckner
Rating: ***** out of *****.
Protanopia (2024), the debut feature from writer-director-co-star Matthew Mahler, is a 73-minute masterwork of surreal, experimental horror. Opening with a quote from Leviticus 14:37-38 concerning the cleansing of a leprous house, the symbolism of which gives the following narrative even more of a potent punch, the picture immediately creates a sense of urgent unease. This is with its agile exploitation of noise distortion, creepy commencing credits, and various other unsettling elements. All of these components are incorporated within the first five minutes of the production.
The use of a bright, bold red in these previously stated sections, as well as throughout the totality of the undertaking, cleverly and powerfully reflect the meaning of the title word (an inability to discern the aforementioned crimson color). It also becomes a glorious beacon for the incredibly memorable and haunting imagery utilized to chilling effect in Mahler’s offering. Most impressively, the piece never loses its natural ability to evoke a dread-infused atmosphere, to surprise, or to astonish from an artistic angle with its many stylish flourishes. This is once Mahler settles down to tell his tale after these striking early segments.
Mahler’s plot involves a man, Luke (in an excellent portrayal from Anthony Carey), falling prey to bizarre dreams of an unfamiliar house once his sister, Mallory (in a wonderfully gripping depiction from James Chase), goes missing. What Luke is unaware of is that the strangely behaved Alan Roscoe, Jr. (in an ever-captivating turn from Timothy J. Cox, which ranks as one of the foremost performances from the always reliable actor) has just inherited the home after the recent passing of his father, Alan Roscoe, Sr. (in an eerie and endlessly watchable representation from John Mahler). Luke and Roscoe, Jr. will soon find their paths crossing. This is as Luke’s nightmares seem to bleed out into the open-eyed reality of his waking days.
Concluding with a skillfully underplayed, but nonetheless impactful, finale, the meticulously paced project is a smartly written and deftly directed addition to Mahler’s filmography. It’s filled with contemplative yet organic dialogue and situations. Still, some of the avant-garde ingredients, such as the strobing lights and slow-motion shots, become less engaging the more often they are applied. This is especially true in the second half of the outing. Yet, the endeavor never loses its hypnotic, vice-like spell on its audience. Moreover, the inclusion of such frequently employed constituents as the poetic, ominous voice-over from Mahler, which contain the initial bits of speech heard in the enterprise, are perpetually operative.
Much of the visual strength of the article comes from Mahler’s evocative cinematography. The color palette chosen for the photoplay alternates between foggy gray and a plethora of far more vibrant shades. All of which marvelously fit the sharply honed ambiance of the proceedings. It also gives the presentation the look of both a giallo by Dario Argento and a prototypical 1970’s grindhouse flick. Furthermore, Mahler’s implementation of appropriately moody music, proficient editing, and his stellar illustration of Jack continually enhance the quality of the fabrication.
Correspondingly, the entire cast is first rate. Paula and Barbara Mahler are terrific as Janice and Gladys, respectively. Ross Mahler is outstanding as Jim. Andrea Norell fares just as well as Vanessa. John Heerlein’s rendering of Detective is spellbinding.
Protonapia is daring and ambitious yet credible and grounded. It also demonstrates sufficiently developed yet enigmatic enough to be intriguing characters. Its themes of service, ritual, and routine are quickly established. From herein, they are woven to dramatic, bloodcurdling, relatable, and all around superb consequence.
Boosted by a remarkable exhibition of sound from Nick Bavaro and Carey, the Ronkonkoma, New York-filmed, $2,000-budgeted exercise is an intense, imaginative, and finely crafted venture. It is one that should prove inspiring to aspiring filmmakers and cinephiles alike. Mahler’s latest proudly stands alongside Cameron and Colin Cairnes’ brilliant Late Night with the Devil (2024) as a top-tier genre effort. It is also one of the ten best movies of the year so far.
awordofdreams.com 